BBizSchool Leaders

How to Show Real Interest in a Faculty Position

A committee can admire your record and still hesitate if it doubts you would accept the offer. Interest is not one answer in one interview; it is a pattern the committee sees from your application to your last conversation on campus.

You may think your interest in a job is private. You know whether you want it. Surely that is enough.

It is not. The committee cannot see inside your head. It can only see evidence.

That evidence starts with your application and continues through the screening interview (the short first-round interview, usually by video), the campus visit (the full-day interview at the school, sometimes called a fly-out), and every conversation in between. The committee collects these signals and compares them.

When the signals agree, the committee believes you. When they do not, it starts to wonder.

Why the committee checks your interest at all

A faculty search takes months. If the top candidate refuses the offer, the department may lose the position or have to start again. So the committee does not only ask, "Is this person good?" It also asks, "If we make an offer, will it end the search?"

I wrote about the specific questions the committee uses to test this in the committee's hidden questions. This article is about something wider: how your interest appears across the whole process, often in places you were not watching.

The bad pattern: the split story

Here is a common case. A candidate tells the search chair that the school is a top choice. The same candidate:

  • sends a cover letter that names the wrong department in the second paragraph,
  • cannot name the required course the position is meant to cover,
  • tells one faculty member that teaching the core course is exciting, and tells another that they hope to teach only electives,
  • spends dinner describing which large cities they would prefer to live in.

No single item is a disaster. Together they tell two different stories. I call this the split story: what you say about your interest and what you show about your interest do not match.

When your words and your evidence disagree, the committee believes the evidence.

The cure is not more enthusiasm. It is consistency.

1. Let the application show that you read the advertisement.

Interest starts before anyone meets you. A committee member reading your file can tell in one paragraph whether you wrote for this search or for every search.

You do not need a different letter for every school. You need one paragraph that could belong only to this job. Look at what the advertisement asks for: which courses, which level of students, what research area, what kind of school.

Weak

“I would be honored to join your distinguished faculty and contribute to your mission of excellence in research and teaching.”

Better

“The position asks for someone to teach the undergraduate core in corporate finance and to support the new master’s program in financial analytics. I have taught the core course twice and built the data exercises for my program’s analytics workshop.”

The first sentence could go to any school. The second could only go to one.

2. Ask questions that come from imagining the job.

At the end of every interview, someone will ask whether you have anything to ask them.

Many candidates treat this as a polite ending. It is one of the clearest signals of interest you have, because your questions show what you have already pictured.

A candidate who has not imagined the job asks general questions that could be asked anywhere. A candidate who has imagined the job asks about the first year: what happens in September, who they will work with, how the course they would teach actually runs.

Weak

“What is the culture like here?”

Better

“If I started next fall, the core course would be my main teaching. How many sections run each semester, and do the instructors share a common syllabus or design their own?”

Here are more questions that come from the actual work.

Questions about research support, such as summer funding or data access, are normal in business schools, and you may ask them. Balance matters. If every question you ask is about how to teach less, the committee will notice where your interest lies.

3. Tell the same story to every person.

During a campus visit you may meet ten, fifteen, or more people. You will be tempted to adjust your answers to please each one. Do not.

The research faculty, the program director, the associate dean, and the doctoral students will compare notes, often the same evening. If you told one person that you want to build the analytics elective and told another that you are not interested in new course preparation, they will find out.

Decide your central story before the visit. It should have three parts:

  1. What you study, in two sentences.
  2. What you would teach here, by course name.
  3. Why this position fits the career you want.

Each person may hear a different level of detail. Nobody should hear a different story.

4. Raise real concerns honestly and calmly.

You are allowed to have concerns about a position. Interest does not mean pretending everything is perfect.

Maybe the teaching load (the number of courses you teach each year) is heavier than at the other schools you are visiting. Maybe the school is far from where your family lives. Maybe the department is small and you worry about having research colleagues.

The mistake is either hiding the concern completely or presenting it as a demand before any offer exists. The better path is to ask a direct question that helps you decide.

This is a model of specificity, not text to copy. Notice that it names the concern and asks for information. It does not ask the committee to change anything.

You may decide what personal information to share. Matters that depend on an offer, such as salary or a partner's job, belong in the conversation after an offer, with the chair or the dean.

But what if I truly do not know whether I want this job?

You may be thinking that this advice asks you to fake certainty.

It does not. Early in the process, nobody expects you to know. You are still learning about the position. You can be honest about that and still be credible.

What the committee needs is not a promise. It needs to see that you are seriously considering the job: that you have read the advertisement, pictured the work, and asked questions a future colleague would ask. Serious consideration is believable. False certainty is not.

And if you learn during the process that the position is wrong for you, that is a good result too. Credible interest never means giving up your own judgment.

Interest is not a feeling the committee can see. It is a pattern it can check.

Make the pattern match from the first page of your application to the last handshake on campus.

Tell one true story, and tell it the same way to everyone.

Filed under Interviews & campus visits