BBizSchool Leaders
Market strategy6 min read

Are You Competitive? Study What the Recent Hires Looked Like When They Were Hired

Do not measure your file against a professor's CV five years into the job. Rebuild what recent hires had on the day they were hired, and use that range to plan your search.

You open a department web page late at night. You click on the newest assistant professor. The CV shows four journal articles, two of them in top journals, a best-paper award, a grant, and three courses taught.

You look at your own CV. One paper under review. A job-market paper (the main paper you present to schools). Two semesters of teaching.

You close the page and decide you are not competitive anywhere.

Stop. That comparison is wrong, and it is wrong in a way you can fix.

1. Stop making the five-years-later comparison.

I call this the five-years-later comparison. You compare your record today with a colleague's record after years in the job. Of course you lose. They had years of research time, coauthors, and revisions that you have not had yet.

The committee that hired that person did not see today's CV. It saw the record that existed during the search. That is the only record that tells you what the job required.

Calibrate against the record the school hired, not the career that came after.

2. Find the appointment year before you look at anything else.

Every reconstruction starts with one date: when did this person start the job? Without it, you cannot tell which items came before the hire and which came after.

Look for the start year on the faculty page, in a university news announcement, in the dissertation record, or on a dated CV. The dissertation year is useful. Many business-school hires start the summer after they finish the degree, but not all, so confirm it where you can.

Then work backward. The search usually happened in the academic year before the start date. Anything dated after that is not part of what the committee saw.

3. Record status at the time of hire, not status today.

A paper published in 2025 may have been a working paper during a search in 2022. A course listed today may have been designed after the hire.

Use dated sources to recover the old status. Useful places include:

  • An old CV, if the person posted one online and it is still available.
  • Working-paper dates on public paper repositories.
  • Conference programs from the search year.
  • An archived page from the doctoral program's job-market list, which often shows candidates' papers and fields.
  • The acceptance date or first online date printed on the published article.
Weak

“Hire A: four publications, two in top journals, best-paper award.” (Taken from the current CV.)

Better

“Hire A, started 2022: job-market paper (working paper, later published 2024); one coauthored paper under review per a dated 2021 CV; instructor of record for one undergraduate course. Award received 2024, after hire. Teaching after 2022 not counted.”

The first line describes a professor. The second describes a candidate. Only the second one helps you.

If you cannot confirm a status, write “unknown.” Do not move a later publication back in time because the project “probably” existed. An empty cell is more honest than a guessed one.

4. Build a table, one row per hire.

Do this in a spreadsheet. The structure forces discipline, and you can share it with your adviser later.

Aim for several rows for each type of school on your list. One person may have been hired for an unusual reason: a specific course need, a research center, a partner hire. A small group gives you a range. A range is what you need.

5. Compare like with like.

The word professor covers very different jobs. A tenure-track research position, a clinical position focused on teaching, and a one-year visiting position are not the same market. Neither are a finance department and a management department, even inside the same school.

Keep your rows separated by position type and by field. If your target list includes research-intensive schools and teaching-focused schools, build a separate group of rows for each. Mixing them produces an average that describes no real search.

6. Use the range to sort your list, not to copy anyone.

When your table is done, look at it honestly. For each type of school, ask: where does my record sit inside this range?

  • If your record looks like the middle of the range, those schools are central targets.
  • If your record looks like the bottom of the range, those schools are reaches. Apply to some of them, with your eyes open.
  • If every hire had something you do not have, such as an accepted publication, mark that gap and decide whether it can change before the deadline.

Do not turn this into imitation. If three recent hires in one department studied supply chains, that does not mean your finance paper should grow a supply-chain paragraph. You are measuring the level of the record, not borrowing its topic.

Then take the table to your adviser. A second reader will catch your mistakes in both directions.

7. But public records are incomplete. Is this worth the time?

Yes. You may be thinking that you cannot see the letters, the interviews, the teaching demonstrations, or the committee's debates. That is true. Your table will miss a great deal.

Publications are easy to see in public records. Teaching quality, letter strength, and interview performance are almost invisible. So your table measures only part of what the committee weighed. Say that to yourself every time you read it.

But an incomplete picture of the right thing is better than a complete picture of the wrong thing. The five-years-later comparison is precise and useless. Your table is rough and relevant.

The newest professor on that web page was once a candidate with an unfinished paper and a nervous cover letter. That is the person you are competing with.

Find that person in the records. Measure yourself against them.

Compare yourself with the candidate they hired, not the professor they became.

Filed under Market strategy