BBizSchool Leaders

Why the Committee Asks Whether You Will Really Take the Job

The committee is not only choosing the strongest scholar. It is trying to finish the search, so it quietly tests whether you would accept an offer. Here is how to hear those questions and answer them.

Candidates like to imagine the search as a contest of merit. The best paper wins. The most promising researcher wins. The most impressive job talk wins.

That is only half of it.

The department needs a person in the empty office in August. A strong candidate who says no to the offer does not fill it.

Think about what a failed search means for the people interviewing you. The required course still has no instructor, so someone else teaches an extra section. The committee may have to start again next year. The dean may decide the position is not needed after all and move the money elsewhere. Months of reading files, holding screening interviews, and hosting visits produce nothing.

None of this is exciting. All of it is real.

So the committee asks a second question about every finalist: if we make this offer, will this person actually accept it?

The question you will never hear directly

Nobody will ask, "Are you going to turn us down?" That would be awkward, and you would simply say no.

Instead, the question arrives in smaller pieces, often in the screening interview (the short first-round interview, usually by video) and again during the campus visit (the full-day interview at the school). The questions sound like small talk. They are not.

Most candidates answer them with what I call the any-school answer: warm, general praise that could be sent to sixty schools without changing a word.

  • "Your outstanding faculty and collegial culture make this an ideal fit."
  • "I have always admired your school's commitment to excellence."
  • "I am open to anywhere that values research."

The committee has heard these sentences many times. Some members have said them in their own interviews. They tell the committee nothing about whether you will come.

Here are the hidden questions, and how to answer each one with something concrete.

1. “What attracts you to this area?”

The hidden question: can you picture yourself living here, or is this a place you will leave at the first chance?

This matters most for schools outside large cities. A committee that has lost candidates to more famous locations will listen carefully.

Do not produce a travel brochure. Do not claim a love for a city you saw for the first time yesterday. Give one or two true, practical reasons.

Weak

“It seems like a beautiful area with a lot to offer.”

Better

“I grew up in a mid-sized city, and I work better with a short commute and time to write. I also noticed how many manufacturing firms are in the region. That matters for my research on supply-chain decisions.”

If location is neutral for you, say so honestly and point to the work: "Location is not the deciding factor for me. The position is."

2. “What would you add to our department?”

The hidden question: have you thought about this specific job, or only about getting a job?

Answer with the actual work. Name the course you can take responsibility for. Name the students you would teach. Name a research link only if it is real.

This is a model of specificity, not text to copy.

3. “Would this teaching load work for you?”

The hidden question: will you be unhappy here and start looking for another job after two years?

The teaching load is the number of courses you teach each year. A "2-2 load" means two courses each semester. Research schools usually have lighter loads; teaching-focused schools usually have heavier ones.

If you have trained at a research-intensive program and are interviewing at a school with a heavier load, the committee will wonder whether you see this job as a temporary stop. Answer the worry directly.

Weak

“Sure, I can handle it.”

Better

“Yes. I want a position where teaching is a real part of the job. I have planned my research around two projects with data I already have, so I can keep publishing during the semester and do the heavier writing in the summer.”

4. “What does your family think about the move?”

The hidden question: is there a personal reason you might say no?

Be careful here. In the United States, employers may not make hiring decisions based on marriage, partners, children, or family plans, so universities train interviewers not to ask about them. Some still ask, often by accident and in a friendly way, at dinner.

You do not have to share private information. You choose what to say. A neutral answer is always available.

If you choose to share more, that is your decision. If you need to discuss a partner's career or other personal matters, you can raise them later, after an offer, with the chair or dean. For anything that involves legal rights or work visas, speak to HR and a qualified attorney.

5. “Where else are you interviewing?”

The hidden question: are we your backup?

You do not need to list your other schools. You also should not pretend you have no options. Say that you are in other searches, and say what makes this one serious for you.

Do not act uninterested to look valuable

Some candidates think looking uninterested creates value. They act a little bored, hoping the committee will chase them. Or they make a teaching-focused department prove that it deserves their research training.

This backfires. It tells the committee the search may fail at the offer stage. Worse, it tells them that even if you accept, you may leave quickly. Coolness does not create bargaining power before an offer exists. It removes you from the list.

But what if I am not sure I want this job?

You may be thinking that this advice asks you to pretend.

It does not. You do not need to declare lifelong devotion. You do not need to call any place your dream school. Strong emotion is not believable after one day on campus, and the committee knows it.

You only need to show that you have pictured the actual job: the course, the students, the load, the place. If you can do that honestly, your interest becomes believable. If you truly cannot picture it, that is useful information for you too.

For how interest shows up across the rest of the process, from your application to the questions you ask, see how to show real interest in a faculty position.

The committee is not asking these questions to trap you. It is trying to protect a search it has worked hard on.

Give them a clear reason to believe you.

Specific answers fill empty chairs. General praise leaves them empty.

Filed under Interviews & campus visits