Research School or Teaching School? Decide Which Job You Want Before You Apply
A research-intensive appointment and a teaching-intensive appointment share a title but not a working life. Decide honestly which one you want before you apply, because committees can tell when you have not.
Many business PhD candidates build their job list the same way. Research schools at the top. Teaching schools underneath. Apply to everything. Decide later, if there is anything to decide.
It feels like a plan. It is not one.
It is a ranking by prestige, and prestige does not tell you what your days will look like for the next six years. It also does not tell a committee why you want their job.
Both kinds of schools advertise an “Assistant Professor” position. The title is the same, but the work is different enough that you should treat them as two professions.
So decide which one you want before you apply. Not after the offers. Before.
1. Understand that the same title hides two different jobs.
At a research-intensive business school, the main job is producing published research. The teaching load is often lighter, for example a 2-2 load (two courses each semester) or less. Tenure depends mostly on publications in highly ranked journals. Your week is built around protecting time to write, revise, and respond to reviewers.
At a teaching-intensive school, the main job is teaching students well across a wider range of courses. The load is often heavier, for example 3-3 or 4-4. Research still matters at many of these schools. Accreditation bodies such as AACSB (the main international accreditor of business schools) expect faculty to stay professionally or academically active. But the center of the week is the classroom, the student, and the course.
Loads and expectations vary widely, even between departments at one school. Read each advertisement and the school's own description of the job. But the difference in what fills the week is real.
2. Compare two ordinary weeks, not two reputations.
Remove the school names. Remove the rankings. Remove the city. Look only at the work.
You revise a paper that was rejected last month. You run a new analysis for a coauthor. You meet a doctoral student. You teach one section of an elective. You protect two mornings for writing and refuse a committee request to keep them.
You teach three sections of the core finance course and one elective. You hold office hours for students who did not understand discounting. You rewrite an assignment that failed last term. You advise a student club. You find two hours on Friday for a paper with a colleague.
Both weeks are full. Both are serious work. Now ask the honest question: which week leaves you tired in a way you can respect? Which tiredness would you accept for years?
That answer is more useful than any ranking.
3. Stop writing the fallback application.
When a candidate has not decided, it shows. The most common form is what I call the fallback application: an application to a teaching school, written by someone who sees the job as a second choice.
Sentences like these appear in files every year:
- “While my primary focus is research, I also enjoy teaching.”
- “I am passionate about student learning and would be delighted to teach your students.”
- “I am confident I can teach any course in the department.”
- “Your school would allow me to continue my research agenda.”
Each one tells the committee the same thing. The writer has not thought about the job this school is actually offering. The first sentence puts teaching second in a job where teaching comes first. The last one describes what the school can do for the candidate, not what the candidate will do for the students.
Committees at teaching schools read many of these. A file that treats their job as a backup is easy to recognize and easy to set aside.
The fallback problem also runs the other way. A candidate who truly wants to teach, but who applies to research schools because advisers expect it, may write a research statement with no real program behind it. That is also a fallback application. It is aimed at a different target.
4. Ask yourself four honest questions.
Write your answers down. Do not answer in your head, where it is easy to be vague.
- When a paper is rejected after two years of effort, are you eager to start the next revision, or do you feel relief that it is over?
- When you explain a hard idea to a confused student and they finally understand it, does that feel like your real work, or like a break from it?
- If you had a free week with no obligations, would you spend it on research, on improving a course, or on neither?
- Which kind of colleague do you admire most, and what does that person do all day?
There are no wrong answers. There are only answers you have avoided.
5. Do not confuse what you can do with what you want.
Many strong candidates can do both jobs. They can publish, and they can teach. That is good news. It does not answer the question.
Capability is not desire. You may be capable of a 4-4 load and still find it draining. You may be capable of a demanding publication schedule and still dislike the long silence of the review process.
You may also want different things at different stages of your life. That is normal. But this search is about this job, starting next year. Decide for now.
6. Say your choice in plain words.
Once you have decided, you will be asked about it, often directly. A committee may ask why their kind of school is the right place for you. Answer with the work, not with the school's reputation.
Notice what the script does not say. It does not say “I also enjoy teaching.” It does not call the job a step. It names the work and claims it.
7. But is it not too risky to narrow my search?
You may be thinking that the market is hard, and that choosing one kind of job means fewer chances. That fear is reasonable.
Deciding is not the same as narrowing. You can apply to both kinds of schools. What you cannot do is send both kinds of schools the same undecided file. If you apply to a teaching school, apply as someone who would take that job and do it well. If you would not take it, do not apply.
A smaller list of honest applications usually serves you better than a long list of fallback applications. Each one gets your full attention, and each one says something true.
The title on the offer letter will look the same either way. Your working life will not.
Choose the work first. Then apply as someone who chose it.
Two professions share one title. Know which one you are applying for.