BBizSchool Leaders

The Campus Visit: Why One Objection Beats Five Compliments

Faculty hiring is not a popularity contest. On the campus visit, one serious objection can outweigh a roomful of compliments, so stop giving the department reasons to object.

You finish the campus visit (the full-day interview at the school, sometimes called a fly-out) certain that it went well.

The chair praised your job talk. Two faculty members stayed late at dinner. A doctoral student told you the department was impressed. The associate dean laughed at your joke.

Then the offer goes to someone else.

You counted your supporters. The department counted its risks.

This is the part of the market that candidates misread most often. A campus visit is not a vote where the most compliments win. It is a group trying to answer one question: is there any reason we cannot live with this person for the next six years?

Why one objection carries so much weight

A faculty appointment is not a conference invitation. It creates years of shared teaching, curriculum meetings, recruiting, promotion votes, and daily contact in the same hallway. The person who hires you will also sit with you in faculty meetings, share the required course with you, and vote on your tenure case.

So the group does not add up praise and subtract complaints. It looks for problems that will last.

Five people can say, "Strong talk, pleasant at lunch." One person can say, "I do not trust the judgment I saw in that meeting." In many departments, that one sentence ends the discussion. Nobody wants to be the colleague who ignored a warning and then had to work with the result.

Remember that.

You do not win the visit by collecting fans. You win it by giving nobody a serious reason to object.

This does not mean you should be bland. Have an argument. Defend your research design. Say clearly what your paper changes. A forgettable candidate also loses.

What you must stop doing is what I call the manufactured objection: a reason to reject you that did not exist before you created it yourself, during the visit, with your own words. Here are the five most common ones.

1. Do not brag about your standards.

Sentences like these are said on campus visits every year:

  • "Honestly, my method is far more rigorous than most of what gets published in this area."
  • "I only really want to target the top three journals."
  • "Your doctoral students would get much better training working with me."

The speaker thinks this shows ambition. The listener hears something else. The person across the table may publish in exactly the area you just dismissed. You have not shown high standards. You have shown that you will be difficult to work with.

Let your work show your standards. Your words should show your judgment.

2. Treat every person on the schedule as a decision-maker.

Your schedule includes the famous senior scholar. It also includes a junior faculty member, the director of the undergraduate program, a clinical professor (a faculty member hired mainly to teach), and the staff coordinator who booked your hotel.

Every one of them has opinions. Many of them will be asked for those opinions.

Candidates often save their energy for the most senior person and treat everyone else as a break. Committees notice this. So do deans. A candidate who only respects status is announcing how they will treat colleagues after they are hired.

Give the 4:00 p.m. meeting with the program director the same attention as the 10:00 a.m. meeting with the chair.

3. Do not take sides in department disagreements.

Every department has old arguments. During your visit, someone may invite you into one.

  • "Our curriculum is ten years out of date, don't you think?"
  • "Between us, experimental work is not really serious evidence."
  • "You will see that one colleague always blocks every change."

Do not agree. Do not disagree. You do not know the history, and the people on the other side will hear about your answer before you reach the airport.

Turn the question back to the work.

4. Answer challenges without defending your whole dissertation.

In the job talk (your research presentation to the faculty), someone will question a choice you made. Maybe your identification strategy (the method you use to show cause and effect), maybe your sample, maybe your measure.

The weak response is a long, nervous speech that covers every robustness check you have ever run. The questioner did not ask for that. The room stops listening. You look unsure of the one choice that was questioned.

Explain the choice. Name the tradeoff. Stop.

Weak

“Well, that is actually addressed in Appendix C, and also we ran it four other ways, and the reviewers at my last conference asked the same thing, and if you look at Table 7…”

Better

“Good question. I use firm-level variation because the policy changed at the firm level. The cost is that I cannot separate effects across divisions. I think the main result holds, but that is a real limit, and it is the next study.”

Defensiveness is not rigor. It is fear presented as rigor.

The same rule applies to teaching questions. A faculty member says, "Our MBA students cannot handle that much coding."

Weak

“Then the curriculum is behind. Students need to learn it.”

Better

“I would first learn where students start. I can keep the technical standard high and still order the material so they succeed early and build toward the harder work.”

The first answer insults the program. The second answer shows you would solve the problem with them.

5. At dinner, you are still a candidate.

Dinner feels relaxed. That is exactly why it is dangerous.

There is wine. The faculty share stories about the dean. Someone asks how your advisor treats students. It feels like friendship.

The interview has not ended. Do not complain about your advisor, your program, other candidates, journal reviewers, or students. Do not repeat gossip you heard earlier in the day. Drink little or nothing; you are allowed to order water without explaining why.

The private comment you make at dinner can become part of the committee discussion the next morning.

But will I not seem boring if I am this careful?

You may be thinking that a careful candidate looks like a candidate with no personality.

No. Careful is not the same as empty. You can be warm, curious, and direct. You can disagree about research. You can say your work challenges a common view in the field.

The difference is the target. Disagree with ideas, politely and with evidence. Do not attack people, programs, or colleagues you just met. A committee is happy to hire someone who argues well. It is not happy to hire someone who creates conflict on the first day.

The visit feels like a test of how impressive you are. It is really a test of whether a group can work with you.

You cannot control every reaction. You can stop creating objections.

Give them your best ideas, and give nobody a reason to say no.

Filed under Interviews & campus visits